Featured Sponsor
Mutual Funds: What, Me Worry?
Published May 09, 2007
The mutual fund industry, which has long resisted any attempts at shareholder activism, may be the missing link in the push for corporate action on climate change.
There are many things to dislike about the mutual fund industry -- high fees, subpar returns, marketing that encourages investors to chase performance -- but one of the most infuriating is the way that funds fail to use the power of the proxy.
A striking example: Not one of the nation's 100 largest mutual funds voted its shares in 2006 to support shareholder resolutions calling for more disclosure on the financial impact of climate change.
That's the finding of a study released by Ceres, a coalition of institutional investors and environmental groups, which asked Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) to compile proxy voting data on the big mutual fund families. The funds that opposed all the shareholder resolutions on global warming include Fidelity (no surprise, since the fund giant tends to vote with corporate management more than most), American Funds and Vanguard.
By contrast, many other institutional investors, including TIAA-CREF, and California's two largest pension funds, CalPERS and CalSTRS, have backed global warming resolutions in growing numbers - with voting support levels reaching a record high of 39 percent at some 2006 annual meetings. I haven’t checked but I’d bet that the socially-responsible funds backed the resolutions.
"Mutual funds are a critical missing link in the push for better corporate disclosure about climate risks and opportunities," said Mindy Lubber, the president of Ceres, in a news release. Climate change, she said, will have a substantial impact on many business sectors, "whether from rising insurance losses from natural disasters, compliance costs from new carbon-reducing regulations or growing global demand for climate-friendly technologies." It seems reasonable to ask corporate managers to tell their owners how they are planning for such eventualities.
A total of 30 climate-related resolutions were filed last year with U.S. companies, including insurance companies, utilities, oil producers, automakers, homebuilders and retailers. Some were withdrawn, but others that went to a vote received support levels as high as 39 percent at Standard Pacific, a California-based home builder, and 22.6 percent at Dominion Resources, a Virginia-based energy company. The average support level of resolutions going to a vote in 2006 was 17 percent.
Co-op America, a nonprofit group that promotes corporate responsibility, is encouraging mutual fund investors to contact American Funds, Fidelity and Vanguard, and ask the funds to vote responsibly on climate-related resolutions. Co-op America says it has generated more than 10,000 emails and letters already from its website.
Part of the problem is that fund families like Fidelity and American compete to manage the 401(k) programs of big corporations. (My plan at Time Warner is managed by Fidelity.) They are therefore inclined to support management and oppose resolutions from independent shareholders. This is not, needless to say, the way corporate governance is supposed to work.
There are many things to dislike about the mutual fund industry -- high fees, subpar returns, marketing that encourages investors to chase performance -- but one of the most infuriating is the way that funds fail to use the power of the proxy.
A striking example: Not one of the nation's 100 largest mutual funds voted its shares in 2006 to support shareholder resolutions calling for more disclosure on the financial impact of climate change.
That's the finding of a study released by Ceres, a coalition of institutional investors and environmental groups, which asked Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) to compile proxy voting data on the big mutual fund families. The funds that opposed all the shareholder resolutions on global warming include Fidelity (no surprise, since the fund giant tends to vote with corporate management more than most), American Funds and Vanguard.
By contrast, many other institutional investors, including TIAA-CREF, and California's two largest pension funds, CalPERS and CalSTRS, have backed global warming resolutions in growing numbers - with voting support levels reaching a record high of 39 percent at some 2006 annual meetings. I haven’t checked but I’d bet that the socially-responsible funds backed the resolutions.
"Mutual funds are a critical missing link in the push for better corporate disclosure about climate risks and opportunities," said Mindy Lubber, the president of Ceres, in a news release. Climate change, she said, will have a substantial impact on many business sectors, "whether from rising insurance losses from natural disasters, compliance costs from new carbon-reducing regulations or growing global demand for climate-friendly technologies." It seems reasonable to ask corporate managers to tell their owners how they are planning for such eventualities.
A total of 30 climate-related resolutions were filed last year with U.S. companies, including insurance companies, utilities, oil producers, automakers, homebuilders and retailers. Some were withdrawn, but others that went to a vote received support levels as high as 39 percent at Standard Pacific, a California-based home builder, and 22.6 percent at Dominion Resources, a Virginia-based energy company. The average support level of resolutions going to a vote in 2006 was 17 percent.
Co-op America, a nonprofit group that promotes corporate responsibility, is encouraging mutual fund investors to contact American Funds, Fidelity and Vanguard, and ask the funds to vote responsibly on climate-related resolutions. Co-op America says it has generated more than 10,000 emails and letters already from its website.
Part of the problem is that fund families like Fidelity and American compete to manage the 401(k) programs of big corporations. (My plan at Time Warner is managed by Fidelity.) They are therefore inclined to support management and oppose resolutions from independent shareholders. This is not, needless to say, the way corporate governance is supposed to work.
Easy Solutions to Energy Problems
Climate Wise: Exxon Mobil: The Rest of the Story
In the just-published State of Green Business 2010 report, we take an extensive look at the data behind the move toward making mainstream businesses greener.
Click here to read all of our in-depth coverage of the State of Green Business, and to download the report.
In 2010, we're bringing our acclaimed State of Green Business Forum to San Francisco and Chicago, digging in to the research in the annual State of Green Business report to discover recent trends in green business and hear from industry experts about what the future will hold. Read all our coverage of the events here.
Advertisement
Featured Resources
The People's Republic of China is going green faster and more thoroughly than almost...
With the rise and fall of the Copenhagen Climate Summit, the business world is sizing up...
How are companies considering carbon now that the Copenhagen summit is behind us? Did the...
This video of Saul Griffith's lightning-paced presentation at the State of Green...
In this panel discussion from the State of Green Business Forum 2010, sustainability...
These tools and resources from some of the world's largest IT companies serve as a...
Advertisement
Professional Services Directory
Find great professional service providers who specialize in green business. GreenBiz.com's Professional Services Directory lists great resources in sustainability strategies, energy efficiency, marketing, supply chain, recruiting and HR, and many more.
Site Sponsors
Get the latest insights from IBM on best practices in sustainable enterprises, and a framework for crafting energy and environmental policies. Find out more here.
Walmart Sustainability Index

Get the story behind the Walmart Sustainability Index and what it means to your business. Read news stories and insights from Joel Makower, Marc Gunther, and the GreenBiz editors.
A monthly metric on responsibility, information, and purchasing in the green economy. The Green Confidence Index is the first ongoing consumer study of its kind. Learn More.
Sponsored Links
Recent News
- Chicago's Green Economy Grows, But Struggles Remain: The State of Green Business Forum-Chicago
GreenBiz.com - Green Policies Can Add Billions to the U.K.'s Budget
GreenBiz.com - KKR Extends Green Program to a Fifth of Global Portfolio
GreenBiz.com - Greener Fleets Hit the Streets: The State of Green Business 2010
GreenBiz.com - Novo Nordisk Slashes Emissions and Water Use, But Sees Waste Grow
GreenBiz.com - Geoengineering -- Our Responsibility to the World: State of Green Business Forum 2010
GreenBiz.com - Strong Federal Energy Policies Could Jumpstart Midwest Manufacturing, Report Finds
GreenBiz.com - Has the Economy Helped or Hurt the Growth of Green Business?
GreenBiz.com - Will Carbon Reduction Commitments Hurt U.K. Green Data Centers?
GreenerComputing.com - Copenhagen Accord Pledges Filed, Warts and All
Recent Blogs
- Why Green Business is Like Teen Sex
GreenBiz.com - How to Shape a Global Approach to Climate Change: More Davos, Less Denmark
- Will the Separation of Powers Kill Climate Change Action in the U.S.?
GreenerBuildings.com - 'Faith-Based' Economics and the Stimulus Package
GreenBiz.com - Are Suppliers Doing Enough on Climate Change?
- Small Changes Can Drive Big Impacts in Greening Fleets
GreenBiz.com - Leading Firms Set Industry Standards for Emissions Management, CDP Report Finds
- How Davos Delivered on Its 'Rethink, Redesign, Rebuild' Theme
GreenBiz.com - GE and Washington: Too cozy?
GreenBiz.com - How to Use 12 Principles of Permaculture to Grow Sustainable Organizations
GreenBiz.com

Browse
Engage
Research



