Featured Sponsor
A Currency for the Wealth, and Environmental Debt, of Nations
Published April 28, 2007
In order to survive and thrive in the face of climate change, we need to establish and then put into practice -- as quickly as possible -- markets that utilize the value of carbon.
The development of human civilization has followed a series of scientific and technological innovations -- starting with harnessing fire and domesticating plants and animals, the evolution of increasingly convenient energy sources, powerful personal communications and computing devices -- that have made our relatively quick progress possible. Looming advances include distributed energy systems, nanotechnology, and the pervasive use of genetic technologies for plants, and potentially for humans as well.
But as a physicist who is focused on energy science, technology and policy related to climate change and the fates of rich and poor nations, when I look at the next fifty years, I believe financial and economic change are essential if we want to safeguard the future of Mother Earth.
Over and over again, it is a financial revolution that I see as needed to change our mindset about the value of the environment -- and of our relationship to the planet and the world we leave the generations to come. That is not to say that we don't need scientific and technological advances -- arguably we need these at rates never before achieved in the energy sector -- but that our inability to value nature stands today as a fundamental obstacle in our appreciation of both nature and ourselves.
There have arguably been three fundamental stages in our economic "meta-history." First, the development of a monetary system, and hence, and perhaps tautologically, a value of money. Second, we evolved a sense and a sensibility of the value of time. Each of these added sophistication -- and complication -- to human transactions. While money provides the means evolve beyond barter, the value of time provides a measure of the pace of change, and the opportunities that we both face and create.
Now, we are poised on the edge of third financial revolution, the value, and cost, of carbon. Unlike the first two, the value of carbon brings our financial assessments back in touch with nature in rather remarkable ways.
The capacity of the biosphere -- the ocean, air, and terrestrial systems -- to absorb carbon emissions, and the extent to which that carbon subsequently transforms nature, is at the heart of the value of carbon. In many respects, of course, it is not the value, but the cost of carbon that I am discussing.
We do not yet know in what range the cost of carbon will float. Some say $20 -- 30 per ton of carbon, some argue $100, some say even higher. What we do know, however, is that like all currencies, it is a monetary proxy for a wide range of resources and processes. In this case, the cost of carbon reflects something never before quantified, the health of the planet.
The pre-industrial concentration of atmospheric carbon was about 270 parts per million by volume. We recently passed 370 parts per mission of carbon -- an event that was marked by environmentalists with a "party" on the Millennium Bridge in London -- and the rate of increase remains steady. Current forecasts of the 'business as usual' scenario are for us triple, or worse, the pre-industrial atmospheric carbon concentration during the coming century, and to eclipse a doubling within the next 50 years.
By all scientific accounts this will fundamentally alter the planet. Many of the effects of this environmental transformation will come as "surprises" as nature does things we had anticipated, and most of these surprises will be bad for our society and our economy.
Our ability to develop a meaningful value of carbon over the next fifty years will be fundamental in our ability to manage environmental change to not only minimize the damage from global warming, but to find ways to address many of the other looming issues we must at some point face. These "next" crises include water shortages, ecological health and resilience, and even arguably the most important social poison we face today -- the incredible poverty in which much of the world lives today and the crippling inequity between the global rich and poor.
We will, indeed we must, find ways to value carbon withinwithin the decade. The question is how soon, and how honestly. If this realization comes late the amount of what is too mildly termed "global warming" will induce severe changes in our society, but if this realization comes sooner, even if halting and geographically patchy initially, the wealth of under-utilized and under-researched technological innovations provides us ample tools to address global environmental change.
That is not to say that today we know how to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions by the 80 percent or more needed to avert a climate crisis, but by starting seriously on that path now, we will -- hopefully -- both have time and interest to learn as we go, and find the suite of technologies, policies, and social transformations needed to protect the planet.
Ironically, a snapshot of a city in 50 years will reflect the technological change, not the economic change in the value of carbon. This future could involve significant amounts of solar, wind, biofuel, nuclear, tidal, geothermal, or other forms of low-carbon energy. It also has a very uncertain role for personal automobiles -- cars will need to become low-carbon modes of transport, but simply building low-emission cars does not begin to address the consumption footprint that cars today represent.
That said, it is the appreciation and valuation of carbon that is needed to facilitate the technological change to a low-carbon society that we know is required.
GreenBiz Editor-at-Large Daniel M. Kammen is the Class of 1935 Distinguished Professor of Energy at the University of California, Berkeley. He co-directs the Berkeley Institute of the Environment and is founding director of the Renewable and Appropriate Energy Laboratory. He has appointments in the Energy and Resources Group and the Goldman School of Public Policy.
In the just-published State of Green Business 2010 report, we take an extensive look at the data behind the move toward making mainstream businesses greener.
Click here to read all of our in-depth coverage of the State of Green Business, and to download the report.
In 2010, we're bringing our acclaimed State of Green Business Forum to San Francisco and Chicago, digging in to the research in the annual State of Green Business report to discover recent trends in green business and hear from industry experts about what the future will hold. Read all our coverage of the events here.
Advertisement
Featured Resources
How are companies considering carbon now that the Copenhagen summit is behind us? Did the...
This video of Saul Griffith's lightning-paced presentation at the State of Green...
In this panel discussion from the State of Green Business Forum 2010, sustainability...
These tools and resources from some of the world's largest IT companies serve as a...
In a world in which vast amounts of information are available about companies and...
This slideshow, a companion to Saul Griffith's lightning-paced presentation at the State...
Advertisement
Professional Services Directory
Find great professional service providers who specialize in green business. GreenBiz.com's Professional Services Directory lists great resources in sustainability strategies, energy efficiency, marketing, supply chain, recruiting and HR, and many more.
Site Sponsors
Get the latest insights from IBM on best practices in sustainable enterprises, and a framework for crafting energy and environmental policies. Find out more here.
Walmart Sustainability Index

Get the story behind the Walmart Sustainability Index and what it means to your business. Read news stories and insights from Joel Makower, Marc Gunther, and the GreenBiz editors.
A monthly metric on responsibility, information, and purchasing in the green economy. The Green Confidence Index is the first ongoing consumer study of its kind. Learn More.
Sponsored Links
Recent News
- Green Policies Can Add Billions to the U.K.'s Budget
GreenBiz.com - KKR Extends Green Program to a Fifth of Global Portfolio
GreenBiz.com - Greener Fleets Hit the Streets: The State of Green Business 2010
GreenBiz.com - Novo Nordisk Slashes Emissions and Water Use, But Sees Waste Grow
GreenBiz.com - Geoengineering -- Our Responsibility to the World: State of Green Business Forum 2010
GreenBiz.com - Strong Federal Energy Policies Could Jumpstart Midwest Manufacturing, Report Finds
GreenBiz.com - Has the Economy Helped or Hurt the Growth of Green Business?
GreenBiz.com - Will Carbon Reduction Commitments Hurt U.K. Green Data Centers?
GreenerComputing.com - Copenhagen Accord Pledges Filed, Warts and All
- Suppliers Lag On Climate Change Strategies, Report Says
GreenBiz.com
Recent Blogs
- Why Green Business is Like Teen Sex
GreenBiz.com - How to Shape a Global Approach to Climate Change: More Davos, Less Denmark
- Will the Separation of Powers Kill Climate Change Action in the U.S.?
GreenerBuildings.com - 'Faith-Based' Economics and the Stimulus Package
GreenBiz.com - Are Suppliers Doing Enough on Climate Change?
- Small Changes Can Drive Big Impacts in Greening Fleets
GreenBiz.com - Leading Firms Set Industry Standards for Emissions Management, CDP Report Finds
- How Davos Delivered on Its 'Rethink, Redesign, Rebuild' Theme
GreenBiz.com - GE and Washington: Too cozy?
GreenBiz.com - How to Use 12 Principles of Permaculture to Grow Sustainable Organizations
GreenBiz.com

Browse
Engage
Research



